Independence Man: John Brown’s Raid, 150 Years Later
A post by Louis A. DeCaro Jr., author of Fire From the Midst of You: The Religious Life of John Brown. Visit his John Brown blog at http://abolitionist-john-brown.blogspot.com/

Although U.S. history buffs will readily remind us that 2009 is the bicentennial of Abraham Lincoln’s birth, not a few will also recall that this year is the sesquicentennial of abolitionist John Brown’s raid on Harper’s Ferry and subsequent hanging by the State of Virginia on December 2. Of course Brown is a controversial figure–at least from the standpoint of many white people. Historically, African Americans have seen Brown fundamentally as a positive figure in history. (Indeed, 2009 is also the centennial of W. E. B. DuBois’s renowned biography of Brown, which remains a perennial favorite despite an abundance of errors in detail.) My own book on Brown, “Fire from the Midst of You”: A Religious Life of John Brown (NYU Press, 2002), which was the first biography of the abolitionist in the 21st century, considers Brown’s intimate friendships and alliances with the black community pre-dating the Harper’s Ferry raid by a decade. In other words, black leaders knew Brown as an ally a good many years before most whites knew of him as an anti-slavery figure.
From a biographer’s standpoint, the 20th century largely belonged to Brown’s detractors. Largely informed by the slave masters’ version of the raid as well as the evasive political approach toward Brown typified by Lincoln’s Republican Party, white society inherited a cynical view of Brown as a well-meaning extremist and fanatic. Although this cynicism was counterbalanced for a time by pro-Brown sympathies among influential abolitionist spokesmen, the well of sympathy for Brown dried up toward the end of the 19th century as white society increasingly distanced itself from the concerns of the formerly enslaved African American. Anti-Brown writers in the North and South published exposes and screeds portraying him as a murderer and brigand, and by the mid-20th century historians like Allan Nevins confidently characterized Brown as insane. This negative view was further encouraged by the popular 1940 movie, “Santa Fe Trail,” the screenplay of which was written by a Virginia native who believed the Civil War was avoidable and that Brown was a deluded fanatic and murderer who helped force the nation in the wrong direction of civil war. As I point out in my book, the black community long recognized the popular bias against Brown prevailing among whites. In 1964, Malcolm X put it most succinctly when he alluded to the same movie, saying that whites had made Brown look like a “nut.”
Read more »
Posted: July 2nd, 2009 under American History, Religion.
Comments: none
| Share this post:










Andrew Ross’s 
Jeri Zeder: How are people receiving your message that the “myth of silence” is just that, a myth?
It is with great sadness the NYU Press notes the passing of one of our authors, Luke Cole, who was killed on Friday, June 6, 2009 in a car accident in Uganda. With co-author Shelia Foster, Luke wrote the now classic