We are all George Zimmerman: Trayvon Martin and the youth control complex

—Victor Rios

In ten years of studying inner city boys labeled at-risk by law enforcement and schools, I have found that poor Black Americans and Latinos are often deemed as culprits, lost causes, and menaces to society. One Black American boy in my study reported that on the day he was born nurses at the hospital commented in front of his mother, “Poor boy. He’s destined to become a dope dealer or drug addict just like his mother.”

In my observations at schools I witnessed a teacher tell a truant Latino eighth grade boy, “You have a prison cell waiting for when you turn eighteen.” On the streets I witnessed a police officer tell a seventeen year old Black American boy, “We want you to kill each other off, that way we don’t have to deal with locking you up.” These kinds of examples are countless in the lives of over 200 boys that I have interviewed and shadowed.

The reality is that poor urban boys grow up surrounded by a system of punitive social control that sees them as deficient students and criminal suspects that must be controlled and contained from young ages. School officials, law enforcement personnel, neighborhood watch volunteers, store clerks, jurors, and everyday citizens perceive and interact with these young people with fear, disdain, and circumspection. This youth control complex, a collective system of negative treatment based on racialized fears of young people of color, is responsible for the criminalization and systematic stripping of dignity that many young people like Trayvon Martin encounter on a day-to-day basis.

George Zimmerman is not just an outlying overzealous rogue vigilante that hunted down an innocent Black American boy. He very much represents mainstream America. We–schools, law enforcement, the media, intellectuals, politicians, and everyday citizens–are all involved in a system that creates and perpetuates fear and outcaste of a vulnerable, marginalized segment of our population. These young people grow up feeling hopeless, undignified, and failed by the system.

As Ronny, a seventeen year old Black American boy I followed for three years puts it, “It’s like I’m invisible, like I don’t exist, like people see me as good for nothing but to be in jail.” This youth control complex produces social death among many young people of color; they are alive but are not recognized as fellow human beings with the right to live productive lives. Instead we rely on surveillance, policing, prison bars, and stand your grounds laws to control, contain, incapacitate, and eliminate them.

The difference between George Zimmerman and the rest of us is that he pulled the trigger. We simply continue to mundanely mete out punitive treatment, stigma, and systematic stripping of dignity to young people of color, slowly killing their soul and their right to pursue happiness. By the time we sit in a courtroom to determine whether Trayvon Martin’s life is worth imposing a sanction on George Zimmerman, five white jurors have already been socialized and acculturated to criminalize young racialized bodies and to view the victim as a culprit.

Politicians and school and law enforcement administrators (including those that supervise neighborhood watch programs) must demand that individuals who interact with a diverse population be trained in understanding their cognitive biases and how these inform the treatment they impose on others. We must train ourselves to recognize and eliminate our inclinations to perceive and treat young people of color as suspects and instead treat them with the dignity they deserve. Listening to the voices of young people themselves who have lived a lifetime of encounters with the youth control complex might be a good first step.

Dr. Victor Rios is a  Professor of Sociology at the University of California, Santa Barbara. He is the author of Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys (NYU Press, 2011) and Street Life: Poverty, Gangs, and a Ph.D.

4 Comments on We are all George Zimmerman: Trayvon Martin and the youth control complex

  1. Awesome article; not many people have actually mentioned the socialization of the jurors themselves. It’s like the average person believes that jurors are just these unbiased random people who have an understanding of what is being explained (more like yelled passionately) to them. The jury selection process is a disgustingly political one and is incredibly flawed in that it always produces *the most* biased jury. Everyone has their biases, and if a community wants an authoritative justice system, they are beholden to the inherent biases in that system; the unfortunate thing is that many people do not understand that last important point.

  2. I really appreciated this piece. This case is a microcosm of our larger society’s tendency to blame the victim for white racism.

  3. I’d love to see what the author has to say about the sociology of the white racist culture, because I’ve seen tons of individuals point out his character as being an okay reason for him to be shot and killed. Pathetic.

  4. Thank you for writing this moving article and for reminding us of the work we all must do in order to become a better nation. I hope that Trayvon Martin’s tragic death moves us as a nation to look within ourselves and re-evaluate what “liberty and justice for all” really means to us. Sadly, this young man is yet another casualty of racial inequality within our society. Until we can admit and confront our own faults as a society and as a nation, this type of needless violence will continue as it does every day.

1 Trackbacks & Pingbacks

  1. What SUP from Your Favorite University Presses, July 26, 2013 | Yale Press Log

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


*